Everyone But You follows the life of Denver musician Eric Shiveley who, in late 2005, sold his house and bought 40 acres in no mans land Colorado. After getting fed up with unfulfilled dreams, he decides to build a house himself.
The film follows him, as he tries to make sense of his life, as well as answer the questions that plague us all. When not doing recording work for musician friends or playing in little gigs, he tries to win the heart of the most beautiful girl he knows. We see his life in detail as he follows his heart in search of something greater, all on a $350 Wal-Mart camcorder.